# Version 14 — Quality review and release gates

**Overall result: QA packaging PASS / Production release BLOCKED.** This is a review and acceptance-test package, not a newly implemented hosted product. No student exam content or scoring logic was modified.

## Verified or supported by prior owner-led QA
- Version 13 baseline included; complete source copy has identical hashes (see JSON results).
- Three approved exam originals and three connected offline copies preserved.
- 180-day offline demo presentation and first-exam-start behavior were observed in the previous review.
- Student self-test score history (90% highest, 75% latest, 80% Timed) and independent modes were observed.
- Admin pause/resume, required reason dialogs, reason log, and CSV demos passed earlier user-guided review.
- A developer QA-only event containing **48 of 60 (80%)** was shown on the admin integration status panel. The panel indicated that the result was included in the export. The actual new export was **not independently inspected here**.
- Screen validations are not equivalent to a full backend test: the demo uses browser-local storage.

## Release blockers — require developer build + evidence
| Gate | Requirement | Status |
|---|---|---|
| G01 | Secure hosted authentication for students and administrators (sessions, password reset, MFA for admins) | BLOCKED — not implemented |
| G02 | Server-authoritative 180-day entitlement, pause, extend, resume, reset, and expiry | BLOCKED — offline demo only |
| G03 | Payment integration with verified webhook, idempotency, refund/chargeback rules | BLOCKED — offline demo only |
| G04 | Employer email ownership proof and approved-domain authorization, including municipal non-.gov domains | BLOCKED — offline demo only |
| G05 | Durable storage, access controls, backup and restore test, audit logging | BLOCKED — offline demo only |
| G06 | Production exam delivery, genuine attempt persistence, secure protected question assets | BLOCKED — offline demo only |
| G07 | Independent item-level 2024 IRC correctness, references, answer keys, rights review | BLOCKED — signoff not furnished |
| G08 | Security testing (cross-account access, injection, tampering, payment replay) | BLOCKED — not tested on production build |
| G09 | Remove QA-only controls and fixtures from public production build | BLOCKED — production build not created |
| G10 | Legal/site policies, owner approval and live-domain/deployment readiness | BLOCKED — decisions outstanding |

## Improvements already identified
- When a QA simulation is selected, show a visible **Recorded** confirmation and briefly disable that button to stop accidental repeated clicks. This is a recorded UI requirement; the approved exam questions stay unchanged.
- Surface clear notices that developer tools are not available to students in production.

## Preservation rules
1. Approved three 60-question exam HTML originals must stay byte-identical unless a separately documented content defect is reviewed and authorized.
2. Retain 585-row master baseline; do not merge/rewrite bank items merely to unify the three exams. The approved exam-specific sheet is the source for the final three exams.
3. The 180-day term supersedes prior 60-day proposals. Unlimited retakes while active; past results remain readable after expiration, while new/resumed exams are blocked.
4. Reuse previously passed demonstration tests rather than asking the owner to repeat them without a real implementation change.
